Man made racist remarks to hotel worker

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, July 22, 2010
Profile image for This is Devon

This is Devon

A BARNSTAPLE man has been convicted of making a racist remark to an Egyptian hotel worker.

Richard Loder, 37, denied racially aggravated harassment of Ramadan Hassan in a Barnstaple hotel car park.

But he was found guilty after a trial at North Devon Magistrates' Court.

Magistrates heard the incident happened after Loder was seen in the car park of the Imperial Hotel with his hand on a Rolls-Royce.

James Ley, a porter and barman at the hotel, said the hotel was hosting a Rolls-Royce convention.

Staff were on high alert following the theft of a Spirit of Ecstasy hood ornament from one of the cars.

For the prosecution, Mark Haddow told magistrates that hotel worker Ramadan Hassan and general manager Martin Felgate came out of the hotel.

Loder was heard to say to Mr Hassan: "What are you talking about?"

He then swore at him and said he should go "back to your own country".

Mr Hassan told the court: "No one has spoken to me like this before. I just choked.

"I have had six years in this country and everyone treats me nicely. I just thought 'Why?' I was confused."

In evidence Loder claimed he told Mr Hassan to stop laughing at him because he was "not even from this country". He said this was not racist, but just a fact.

Mr Haddow said the trial revolved around this one sentence — and both accounts of what was said were equally offensive.

In a police interview, which was read to the court by Mr Haddow, Loder said he did not mean to cause offence.

He said: "I could have called him much worse.

"I know he is Egyptian, but I didn't know that at the time. I thought he was Muslim or something."

Magistrates ruled that Loder's remarks were racist.

Loder, who gave an address in Mulberry Way, Barnstaple, was given a 12-month conditional discharge and ordered to pay £100 compensation to Mr Hassan.

3
Tweet this article
Report

3 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Monzur Rahman, Barnstaple

    Thursday, August 26 2010, 5:19AM

    “I'm surprised at how biased all the comments are. Has anyone actually considered what it was like for Mr Hassan.
    Jack Russel (Sorry to be patronising) but lets take a little spin on this:-
    You see someone at their workplace who is disabled. You can clearly see they are disabled. It is a FACT they are disabled. Would you go about shouting out there disability??
    How about someone who is overweight, jogging in the street??
    Do you see where i'm coming from. Comments which are insulting can affect people in many ways. Think about how it will affect Mr Hassan at work, living with the humiliation with his colleagues”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Jack Russell, North Devon

    Wednesday, July 28 2010, 10:54PM

    “So, let me see if I understand this correctly.............. telling someone, who is not from this country to go back to their own country is deemed to be a 'racist' remark - punishable by the full force of the law ?

    What sort of screwed up world are we living in?

    Enoch Powell was right.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by John Harrison, Newport Barnstaple

    Thursday, July 22 2010, 6:43PM

    “If Mr Hassan had made a similar remark to Mr Loder would the North Devon
    Magistrates give him 12 months conditional discharge and order him to pay
    Mr Loder £100 compensation ?
    I'm not saying that Mr Loder is right what he said but it seems a bit steep to me, surely a caution would be more fitting ?
    I have had people tell me to go back to where I come from, not being from North Devon so can I get £100 compensation ?”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters