How saying sorry cuts youth crime

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, November 17, 2009
Profile image for This is Cornwall

This is Cornwall

MORE than 1,000 Westcountry children have escaped being given a criminal record through a programme that sees offenders make amends for their actions, writes the WMN's Graeme Demianyk.

Devon and Cornwall Police believe that by adopting a more "flexible" approach to "low-level" crime, including graffiti, shoplifting and some public order offences, they can reduce re-offending rates and stop youngsters going to court unnecessarily.

Since the programme's launch last November, 1,031 first-time young offenders aged between 10 and 17 have written letters to victims, painted over graffiti and paid for stolen goods.

Police say they are not being soft on crime, stressing that victims have to agree to the punishments and that the option is not offered to those who show no remorse for their actions.

Devon and Cornwall Police estimate that just 3 per cent of those dealt with so far through so-called restorative justice have gone on to re-offend.

PC Phil Skedgell, Devon and Cornwall Police's restorative justice support officer, said: "It is not avoiding people having a criminal record, it is about doing what is right for the victims and the offenders."

He said victims were "involved in the process" and that they had a "clear voice" because they decided on suitable reparation or punishment.

Devon and Cornwall Police are mirroring a national pilot launched by the Department for Schools, Children and Families. Known as Youth Restorative Disposal, the idea is to avoid jeopardising a young person's future prospects and free officers to deal with more serious crime.

Supporters talk about how restorative justice is a return to a more traditional form of policing, where the proverbial "thick ear from the local bobby" follows from officers having discretion about how they police their communities.

In August, the Western Morning News reported that one million children had been convicted of a criminal offence since Labour came to power – triggering calls for more to be done to keep youngsters out of trouble. The figures emerged as two teenagers who daubed graffiti on a 750-year-old parish church in North Tawton, near Okehampton, Devon, apologised to the congregation.

PC Skedgell said that, when confronted with hoax calls, cyber-bullying and young people using inappropriate language, it was important to "deal with young people in a proportionate way".

About 2,000 front-line staff are trained to use the restorative approach.

PC Skedgell said: "Restorative justice applies to the vast majority of young people making a mistake and an error of judgment growing up rather than an intentional criminal act."

PCSO Sam Smith, based at Camelford in North Cornwall, has used restorative justice on several children in their early teens. She said: "If you are going to commit crime for the rest of your life, you are going to see restorative justice as the easy way out.

"But if it is a one-off, it is the thing that makes sure they don't do it again."

15
Tweet this article
Report

15 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by David Gray, Nairn

    Wednesday, November 18 2009, 1:49PM

    “Charles is absolutely correct with his comments about generations growing up without discipline. But the child is now king and it is perfectly acceptable to change a baby's nappy, in the pub at 11pm (see what happens if you were to compain about that - it would make Charles' point perfectly, as you were sworn at by the parents!). However, an interesting point is that we are currently governed by a state machine with powers and surveillance technology that would make Stalin and Hitler proud. This has had no noticeable effect on the levels of crime or making citizens feel safer, as any of you who dare to venture into the high street of any UK market town on a Friday night will attest. The databases set up by the state do not seem to have prevented the likes of Vanessa George, or Ian Huntly, from committing their crimes and, if anything, will lull us into a false sense of security. There is also the ill thought-out legislation, banning everything that does not fit in with the government's politically correct ideology and criminalising most of the tax-paying public by use of pettyfogging legislation, whilst our government behaves as if it were above the law. All of this whilst making us pay for the priveledge of being governed by people who believe that they know better than us and that we are not intelligent enough to make our own decisions.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Charles Henry 1945-(diuturnity), Somersetshire

    Wednesday, November 18 2009, 12:55PM

    “:| Interesting comments David. . We all made 'mistakes' of course. . :( My wife even insists I still do! . Can you believe it?!!. . However it's only those who still believe in all this 'free expression' nonsense and no discipline of the 'modern' generations. . That can't see what the solution will have to be. . Whilst we have second and third generation scr*tes bringing up scr*tes, and no political will to restore proper discipline and manners in the home or schools; and also a fear of the PC Consequences if they do; nothing will change. . What kept most of us on the straight and narrow, was a clear sense of what's right and wrong. . We had boundaries that we learnt to respect. . The consequences of not doing so were the stuff of the playground legends.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by David Gray, Nairn

    Wednesday, November 18 2009, 11:31AM

    “Not criminalising these youngsters at an early age does seem to be a good idea; I would defy anyone who has posted a comment on here to say that they have never made a mistake when they were in their youth. However, we also need to address the causes of crime at their root source. It seems to me that the example set by this corrupt government is not a good one and if our leaders are seen to behave in such a poor manner (lying to the electorate, expenses fiddles, perceived illegal wars, the gerrymandering that we are likely to see in the run-up to the election), then that becomes the acceptable norm. Neither does it help that, over the last ten years or so, the government have sought to manipulate the crime figures by moving the goalposts - things that are 'crimes' in most peoples' books are called 'antisocial behaviour' by the government. The standard of 'acceptable' behaviour has been lowered to such an extent as to be almost non-existent, along with manners and consideration for others.
    Incidentally, this sort of behaviour is exemplified on here by the rudeness of the comments made by Henry Blince, on a daily basis, who seems to believe that anyone disagreeing with him is wrong and has not got the wit or imagination to accept that there are opinions other than his own.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Charles Henry 1945-(diuturnity), Somersetshire

    Tuesday, November 17 2009, 9:42PM

    “:) That low are you Henry? . . :( Gee.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by henry blince, devon

    Tuesday, November 17 2009, 7:25PM

    “It's not possible to be inferior to you Charles. The scale doesn't go any lower.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters