Wild goats culled in Valley of Rocks

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, July 02, 2009
Profile image for This is NorthDevon

This is NorthDevon

NINE goats from the Valley of Rocks in North Devon have been put down for health reasons.

The feral goats were among a herd of 170 that were rounded up and checked by vets.

Many more are expected to be culled later in the year to reduce the herd to between 45 and 80.

The round-up of goats last week was carried out by Lynton Town Council, Diana Lewis, of North Devon Animal Ambulance, and Market Vets.

They said the purpose of the exercise was to check the health of the animals.

A second round-up, at which the numbers will be radically reduced, is for the sake of the long-term health of the herd.

Town councillor Julian Gurney said: "If a farmer had a flock of sheep, they would be 'filtered' with lambs being sent to slaughter for meat and ewes slaughtered when they were too old and no longer financially viable.

"That has never happened with these goats, so their numbers have grown and grown, until they are no longer sustainable in the Valley.

"It's all right in the summer, but in the winter, when there is no grazing, they starve."

He said that in addition, the condition of many of the 170 goats was extremely poor.

"If you had a dog in such a poor condition, you wouldn't let it suffer that way," said Cllr Gurney.

Not all the sick goats could be put down last week, he said: "Quite a lot of nannies were in very poor health, but they were lactating and we didn't know which kid belonged with which nanny. We are unable to put those nannies down until they finish feeding their kids.

"We need goats out there, for conservation grazing, and without them the area would deteriorate until it was woodland and no one wants to lose the Valley."

Diana Lewis said: "The operation went like clockwork. We had a wonderful team and Market Vets were wonderful.

"Everybody, on both sides of the goat debate, put their differences aside for the sake of their welfare, which just goes to prove that when people get together and debate something quietly and sensibly, even the worst problems can be overcome without argument."

Describing the goats she said: "They were teeming with ticks and lice. People going out into the Valley to walk their dogs or to have picnics with their families, don't want to face that, so they had to be dealt with."

The goats were also vaccinated against Bluetongue and liver fluke and had feet and teeth checks.

Later in the year, the numbers will be reduced further on the advice of the vets and of Natural England who have recommended a herd of between 45 and 80 as sustainable in the Valley.

Diana said one of the main reasons for the deterioration in the health of the herd was severe inter-breeding.

4
Tweet this article
Report

4 Comments

  • Profile image for This is NorthDevon

    by Alan, South Molton

    Friday, November 20 2009, 2:02PM

    “With respect to Nick in Kent the council sought expert advice from many sources. The vet who oversaw the round up and health checks specializes in small ruminant population medicine and consulted widely with known experts in the field and experts from Rural England. If the Goat Sanctuary wants to get involved they would be welcome but the idea that this whole operation had not been thoroughly researched and planned is wrong.”

  • Profile image for This is NorthDevon

    by Nick, Kent

    Tuesday, September 01 2009, 10:01AM

    “Can understand the feelings of residents whose gardens are spoiled by the goats. Can also appreciate that some goats are in poor health.


    However the council appears not to have sought advice from the Goat Sanctuary in Kent whose expertise and facilities could save many of the animals. They could also offer advice on management of a goat herd such as controlled castration of billies, provision of foodstuff during winter etc.”

  • Profile image for This is NorthDevon

    by H Robinson, Manchester

    Thursday, July 09 2009, 9:42PM

    “Has Mark from West Yorks actually ever seen any of these goats? I have, as I have visited Valley of Rocks frequently over the past couple of years and the place is teeming with them. There are far too many for such a small area and it can be seen that many are not in good health. A selective cull and careful management will mean that the ones that are left will be in better condition and have sufficient food over the winter period. Lynton would not be the same without the goats but at present they are not always popular with locals due to their destructive ways when faced with a shortage of food in the colder months.”

  • Profile image for This is NorthDevon

    by Mark, West Yorks

    Friday, July 03 2009, 8:27AM

    “Now isn't that interesting! The goats have been regarded as a menace to gardens for so many years, wirth garndiose fencing schemes proposed, the goats subjected to early morning culls ("blood on the grass") and attempted poisonings, but now they are regarded as essential for the "conservation" grazing of the Valley. We just can't stand not being in control can we? Because we can, we round up these "feral" goats and treat them like livestock. Try herding other wild animals like foxes or badgers. Oooops - we kill those as well!”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters