Should smoking on stage be banned?

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, February 19, 2009
Profile image for This is Exeter

This is Exeter

A BUSINESSMAN has claimed that actors who smoked cigarettes on stage during a theatre play in Barnstaple might have sent out potentially worrying "subliminal messages" to children in the audience.

Financial advisor Philip Milton, from Georgeham, said his family thoroughly enjoyed watching Spider's Web — which was written by Agatha Christie in 1953 — at the Queen's Theatre last week.

"It was an excellent production and it was good to see the theatre full on a Friday night, especially in view of the weather," he said.

But he said the smoking by actors on stage during the atmospheric murder mystery sent out "subliminal messages" to children in the audience, not to mention an "unpleasant smell", and the play would not have suffered if no tobacco had been burnt in the theatre that night.

He said the ban on smoking in enclosed public spaces should now be extended to include theatre stages. "I'm not trying to be a party pooper," he was keen to add.

But Alan Giddings, chief executive of North Devon Theatres, said Mr Milton seemed to be "creating smoke without fire".

Mr Giddings said: "If smoking is part of the performance, it's difficult to say it shouldn't happen. It was very brief and an announcement was made to the audience.

"I don't think it sets a standard. There was no notion it was endorsing smoking and at the time the play is set people smoked like chimneys."

The theatre has extractor fans and there has been no complaints about actors smoking. Mr Giddings pointed out that other elements of plays, including murders, were not thought to influence the behaviour of children watching the performance.

The law states that "where the artistic integrity of a performance makes it appropriate for a person who is taking part in that performance to smoke, the part of the premises in which that person performs is not smoke-free in relation to that person during his performance".

Specialist tobacconists, oil rigs, and mental health units are also subject to varying types of exemption from the ban on smoking in public places. Since July 2007, when the ban came into force, anyone flouting the law can be handed a £50 fine.

The smoking ban has been widely obeyed in North Devon with the notable exception of the former landlady of the Stag's Head in Barnstaple, who allowed unfettered puffing in her pub until she was prosecuted by the district council. A detective found a "tobacco fog" and took secret photographs of customers flouting the ban, including an old man who was smoking "a large pipe". The landlady defendant, Joanne Kendall, was fined £130.

And the question of whether or not it is right for performers to smoke tobacco on stage has emerged elsewhere in the UK. Rolling Stones guitarist Keith Richards, for example, was spotted puffing on a fag on stage in London in 2007; Greenwich Council did not fine him, however, saying it was happy the incident was a "one off".

14
Tweet this article
Report

14 Comments

  • Profile image for pluckingbell

    by pluckingbell

    Thursday, February 09 2012, 12:39AM

    “what an old fart”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Kathryn, USA

    Sunday, February 22 2009, 6:30PM

    “Mr. Milton takes his children to a play that is a MURDER mystery and is not concerned that his children might come to see murder as a recreational pursuit because, after all, their father paid to take them to enjoy it. Secondly, this same man states that he does not want to be a "party pooper." Too late...he is. The artistic community would be much better off if theater goers such as Mr. Milton and his children simply stayed home rather than try to define what is and is not necessary in the expression of art. He clearly has no understanding of the concept of artistic expression. Why not, Mr. Milton, simply take the kids to the pub where smokers are banished outside? Or, better yet, crawl into the bubble where you live and stay there.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by steve, Spain

    Friday, February 20 2009, 9:01PM

    “Its idiots like him who helped get smoking banned in pubs and probably dosent even drink in a pub himself.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Jill, Hawaii, USA

    Friday, February 20 2009, 9:00PM

    “The purpose of smoking bans in indoor places open to the public is to keep the air smokefree because many people get sick from smoke. It has been established as an extreme health hazard as well as a fire hazard. If a performance requires smoking-or any kind of "smoke" there is theatrical "smoke" and theatrical cigarettes that do not create actual tobacco smoke. It is not necessary to use real cigarettes, just as it is not necessary to use real blood or drink real liquor if the story line calls for these things.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by mandy, banituk

    Friday, February 20 2009, 6:36PM

    “Well said Paul and others.
    There is always one, isn't there, what a sad life we are all going to have when the next ban comes in, and it will with these sorts of people.
    Yes let us ban Mr Milton, he said the play was full.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Thomas, Devon

    Friday, February 20 2009, 12:02AM

    “Why not just ban everything? keep them all happy, could fine us when ever they need a little extra cash then.

    As far as I am concerned, if I want a black tea i'll ask for a black tea, if I want to sing bar bar black sheep I shall do, and if I want to sing bar bar white sheep, or want a white tea, I shall sing and ask for the afore mentioned.

    There is too many pen pushers, conjuring up ways to fine us even more, the political police just take it too far, the smoking ban I overall agree with, but taking it to the likes of stopping kissing, and such, is just a little too far, soon you won't be able to wear a certain type of pants, or shoes, just incase it MIGHT offend someone else. This country is whack for its rules and regulations.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Babs, Barnstaple

    Thursday, February 19 2009, 11:47PM

    “Milton, AGAIN”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by chas, Little Britain.

    Thursday, February 19 2009, 9:29PM

    “Perhaps Mr Milton should keep his kids indoors in case they see any smokers, specially outside pubs.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Mr Boot, Barnstaple

    Thursday, February 19 2009, 9:21PM

    “Should Philip Milton be banned?”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Smoker, Barnstaple

    Thursday, February 19 2009, 7:17PM

    “Is this the same phillip Milton who had tree fall on his car, some MP that writes tosh just to see his name in print?”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters